I hear some version of this almost every week: "The restaurant down the street adds 3%. My contractor adds 4%. I saw a 5% difference at a store last weekend. Nobody seems to care, so why can't I just add a fee too?"

It is a fair question, and an understandable one. When you see fees everywhere, they start to feel standard. If everyone else is doing it, how complicated can it be?

You may well be able to pass on some of your card acceptance cost. But what you see at someone else's register tells you very little about how their program is set up, whether it follows the rules, or whether the same approach would work for your business.

Is anyone actually enforcing surcharge rules?

Yes, and this surprises a lot of business owners.

In its U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q&A, Visa says it is actively enforcing its surcharge policy, receives numerous consumer complaints and conducts yearly mystery shopping through outside auditors. It also says the acquirer of any merchant identified as surcharging improperly may be assessed an immediate $1,000 fine.

The acquirer is the financial institution behind your ability to accept cards. Visa says the assessment is made to the acquirer. How a merchant may ultimately be affected depends on its processor relationship and merchant agreement.

If a mystery shopper paid at your business tomorrow, or bought something on your website, what would they see?

Can customers report a surcharge?

They can. Visa maintains a public form where cardholders can report a merchant. It specifically lists a U.S. surcharge above 3%, a surcharge that was not shown separately on the receipt, and a surcharge that was not disclosed at the store entrance or point of sale. Visa says the details submitted are investigated to determine whether a rule was violated.

So it is not only auditors. Any customer who notices a fee can report it.

If one of your customers looked closely at your receipt, would the fee appear the way it is supposed to?

If another business has done it for years, isn't it fine?

Not necessarily. Years without a problem is not proof that a program is compliant.

You also may not know what you are looking at. What looks like a 5% fee could be a dual-pricing program, a different type of fee entirely, or a setup that should be reviewed. Their processor, their state and the way they accept payments may all be different from yours.

Copying the sign does not copy the structure behind it.

Not sure which type of program you are looking at? Read: Surcharge, Convenience Fee, Cash Discount or Dual Pricing? Here's the Difference.

Already charging a fee?

Many business owners reading this already have one in place. Someone set it up, and it has been running quietly ever since.

Does it apply only to credit cards, or does it show up on debit cards too? How is it disclosed at the door, at checkout and on the receipt? Does your website or invoicing handle it the same way your register does?

Visa requires a merchant to notify its acquirer before it begins surcharging, and some states restrict surcharging or add requirements of their own. Those details rarely get explained when a program is turned on.

If someone turned this on for you three years ago, how do you know it still follows today's rules?

Why should your processor be part of the conversation?

I cringe a little when a business owner tells me, "I'll just add the fee myself."

Your processor should not decide how you price your business. But a fee program has to be structured correctly, supported by your payment technology and set up under the rules that apply to you.

A fee typed onto an invoice or added at the register can look simple. Whether it holds up is a different question.

So what does your setup actually look like?

The business down the street cannot answer that for you. Neither can the sign at their register.

What would it be worth to know your program is set up the way it should be, before anyone else asks?

Considering a Change? Start With a Payment Review.

Whether you are thinking about passing some of your card acceptance cost to customers or already do, Allure Payments can review how your program is set up and what should be confirmed with your processor. When something needs to change, I handle it with you and remain your direct point of contact after it is done.

Request a Payment Review

Disclaimer

This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal advice. Card-brand rules, processor requirements and applicable laws can change and may vary based on the business and how payments are accepted. Allure Payments provides payment advisory guidance to help merchants understand their options, requirements and implementation considerations. Specific requirements should be confirmed with your processor and, when appropriate, qualified legal counsel before making or implementing a change.

Sources

Visa, U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q&A

Visa, Rules Reporting Form

← Back to Payment Insights