Ask a business owner what they call the fee on their card transactions, and you will usually get a quick answer. A surcharge. A convenience fee. A cash discount. Dual pricing.
Ask what program the account was actually set up for, and the answer usually takes longer.
I understand why. Most of these programs were turned on by a processor, a sales rep or a software company, often years ago. If customers are paying and the fee is showing up, there does not seem to be much reason to look closer.
The problem is that the name on the sign does not decide what the program is. The way the fee is charged, the cards it applies to, how it is disclosed and how your technology handles it do.
In short, a surcharge adds a fee to an eligible credit card purchase. A convenience fee is generally a flat fee for paying through a channel outside the business's normal one. A cash discount lowers the regular card price for customers who pay cash. Dual pricing shows the cash and card prices side by side before the customer pays. Each one follows different rules.
What is a credit card surcharge?
A surcharge starts with one posted price and adds an amount when the customer pays with an eligible credit card.
If the posted price is $100, a cash customer pays $100. A credit card customer might pay $103. A debit card customer still pays $100.
That last line matters. Visa does not permit surcharges on Visa debit or prepaid cards, even if the customer selects "credit" at the terminal. Visa also limits a U.S. credit card surcharge to the merchant's applicable rate or 3%, whichever is lower, and has notice and disclosure requirements that apply before and during the program.
So here is a question worth sitting with. If the fee you call a surcharge shows up on every card your customers use, debit cards included, is it really working the way a surcharge is supposed to?
What is a cash discount?
A cash discount works in the opposite direction. The regular price is the card price, and customers who pay cash receive a lower one.
Using the same example, the card price is $103 for credit and debit alike, and the cash customer pays $100.
Visa says a cash discount must be a reduction from the standard price. A business cannot advertise $100, add $3 at checkout and simply call it a cash discount.
When a customer looks at your prices, which number do they see first? And when they pay by card, does the total come from that price, or from something added at the end?
Where does dual pricing fit?
Dual pricing is closely related to cash discounting. The difference is what the customer sees. Both prices are shown before the customer chooses how to pay.
Card: $103
Visa permits merchants to display the card and cash prices side by side, as long as the card price is properly displayed rather than created by adding a fee at the end of the transaction.
Your prices probably appear in more places than the register: your website, invoices, quotes, menus. Do they all show the same thing?
What is a convenience fee?
A convenience fee is a different animal. Under Visa's general U.S. rules, it is tied to offering a genuine alternative payment channel, different from the way the business normally accepts payment. Visa generally requires it to be a flat amount rather than a percentage, and clearly disclosed.
If your fee is a percentage charged on every card payment, is it a convenience fee? Or is it a surcharge with a different name?
Who set this up, and did anyone explain it?
This is the part most business owners have never been asked about.
A fee program is not just a sign. Your payment system may need to tell credit from debit, calculate the right amount, show the right disclosure and print the right receipt. Ecommerce, invoicing and recurring billing all need to handle it too.
Rules do not stand still either. Some states restrict surcharging, and those requirements can change. Mastercard says it is currently updating its own U.S. surcharge rules, including notification and registration requirements.
Who configured your program? Did anyone walk you through what it is supposed to do? And when was the last time anyone checked whether the setup you started with is still the setup you should be using today?
So which program do you actually have?
If you are not completely sure what your program is, how it was set up or whether it still fits the rules, you are far from alone. Most business owners have never had it explained to them.
What would it be worth to know for certain that the fee your customers see is the one your account is actually built for?
Considering a Change? Start With a Payment Review.
Allure Payments reviews how your fee program is set up, how it appears to your customers and how your technology handles it, so you know exactly what you have. When something needs to change, I handle it with you and remain your direct point of contact after it is done.
Request a Payment ReviewDisclaimer
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal advice. Card-brand rules, processor requirements and applicable laws can change and may vary based on the business and how payments are accepted. Allure Payments provides payment advisory guidance to help merchants understand their options, requirements and implementation considerations. Specific requirements should be confirmed with your processor and, when appropriate, qualified legal counsel before making or implementing a change.
Sources
Visa, U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q&A